The results are in!
Third:

Strong verticality and mood. A balanced composition evoking both scale and temperature.
Second:

A sharp and well-composed photo. I like how the arms create a vignette-like frame, and how the water behind the diver softly blurs out, adding depth.
First:

Exceptional sharpness and foregrounding. The photo conveys a story of craftsmanship, which is evident in the high quality of barrels, the wine they hold, and the photographer who captured the moment.