Portfolio "Survivor"

[steveman]

A group may be strengthened by the elimination of its weakest member.
With that in mind, I have a question....

From this small portfolio of desert shots in black and white, which would you "vote off the island?"

http://www.pbase.com/steveman/bwdesert

Please vote for the weakest image. You're welcome to make all sorts of comments about how bad they all are, but I really want to know which single image you would drop from the group.

Thanks,
Steve Maniscalco
(dazedgonebye)

[markvm]

All are nice. If I had to choose it would be either the first or last image.

[cjburianek]

The first. You have several other saguaro's which are much stronger in composition and the first seems to have the weakest contrast...