Thu Feb 14, 2008 9:35 pm
I don't think you're interpreting this correctly, djwixx.
I'm suggesting that PicLens is either on or off for a particular artist/gallery and that it be off by default.
I'm trying to think of a artist's PBase site as a physical art gallery in some building somewhere. I'll extend this metaphor to the examples you listed.
Slideshow is something you get from doing SLIDESHOW(gallery_name), so that's already an option for the artist to make when they write the description of the gallery. This is like the artist putting in the foyer a television which plays a video displaying selected works of the artist. He has the option of doing this and that's okay.
Treeview only changes how the user finds a gallery, it doesn't change how that gallery is viewed after it's found, though perhaps you have a point that finding that gallery is part of the experience the artist should have control over. Disabling treeview would be like the artist requiring visitors to have ridden a bike to the art gallery. I suppose the artist has the right to refuse any visitor(he owns the building) and he can refuse those that came in a car, but it seems like an awful strange stipulation.
Commenting is possible to disable in the Options sections of the Account Settings linked to from your profile page. There are a few other options besides disable and enable too with regards to commenting. I guess this would be like having a comment box somewhere accessible in the art gallery and it would be up to the artist to have it there, read it, etc.
Guestbooks would be like a register at the building. We do not seem to have any options for guestbooks on PBase(unless the aforementioned Comment options also apply to guestbook comments), and that does seem like it warrants an option as well. It's not so much about how a gallery is experienced, but guestbook options are a fair suggestion that may be worked on after some more crucial things.
Basically, I'm concerned that some artists will not want their galleries viewed in ways that they don't know about. If the artist is okay with their gallery looking the way it does in PicLens, then they can enable PicLens. If we make it an option that affects all galleries, it will probably be in the Account Settings like the options to enable statistics trackers. If we make it an option that affects one gallery at a time, it will have to be in the edit_gallery page.